Difference between revisions of "Road stations"
From #openttdcoop wiki
m (→Final Word) |
m (Marked for update) |
||
| (9 intermediate revisions by 8 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
[[Guides|<< Back to Index ]] | [[Guides|<< Back to Index ]] | ||
| + | {{out of date}} | ||
| + | {{update}} | ||
| − | + | Road stations typically take a back seat to rail stations in #openttdcoop games. Railways have much higher capacities than roadways and trains move much faster than trucks and buses. However, road stations (especially when properly used) can be used to improve parts of a network where a train would be overkill. | |
== 2 Key Points == | == 2 Key Points == | ||
| − | + | Firstly, since the RoRo road stations were introduced it is much better to use these than terminus stations. A terminus road station is as inefficient as a standard terminus rail station. 1 vehicle may enter and leave at a time which greatly reduces efficiency as with the RoRo one 2 may enter and leave at once, that 4 vehicles in play an efficiency boost of 400% if used constantly. | |
| − | + | Routes can be created with the addition of one way roads in a recent nightly, see [http://wiki.openttd.org/Roadway_construction#Building_one-way_roads OpenTTD Wiki: One way roads] for more details. Routing is essential if you want an efficient station. At the moment the best stations I can create for busy road stations is 150-200% as you have to force lorries in and out in 1 direction. If 1-way RoRo stations could be created where road vehicles used both sides of the road in one direction this would boost it up to 300-400%. | |
| − | Routes can be created with the addition of one way roads in a recent nightly, see [http://wiki.openttd.org | + | |
| − | So | + | So the two key points are: |
| − | - | + | - Don't use Terminus stations |
- Always route traffic | - Always route traffic | ||
| Line 16: | Line 17: | ||
To create a good station you need to have enough bays now this is individual to each instance of a road station and must be played about with accordingly. | To create a good station you need to have enough bays now this is individual to each instance of a road station and must be played about with accordingly. | ||
| − | My station concept requires minimal station walking but not in the traditional sense it requires a 1 tile space between each station and its | + | My station concept requires minimal station walking but not in the traditional sense it requires a 1 tile space between each station and its neighbors. |
[[Image:RdStnConcept_gaps.jpg|thumb|center|293px|Gaps must be placed between station tiles]] | [[Image:RdStnConcept_gaps.jpg|thumb|center|293px|Gaps must be placed between station tiles]] | ||
When stations are completed delete walkers. | When stations are completed delete walkers. | ||
| Line 25: | Line 26: | ||
[[Image:RdStnConcept_wr.jpg|thumb|center|350px|Completed with routing]] | [[Image:RdStnConcept_wr.jpg|thumb|center|350px|Completed with routing]] | ||
| + | '''Note: Please use distant-join Stations, How press CTRL while Building. In trunk since r14121.''' | ||
== Exits and Entrances == | == Exits and Entrances == | ||
Where to put them in and pull them out! This decision is one of the most important as it determines whether traffic piles up or flows smoothly | Where to put them in and pull them out! This decision is one of the most important as it determines whether traffic piles up or flows smoothly | ||
| Line 34: | Line 36: | ||
This is my design for a small industry pickup (for a big pickup copy the above design scaling station numbers as required) | This is my design for a small industry pickup (for a big pickup copy the above design scaling station numbers as required) | ||
[[Image:StnConcept_sip.jpg|thumb|center|260px|Small Industry pickup]] | [[Image:StnConcept_sip.jpg|thumb|center|260px|Small Industry pickup]] | ||
| − | In most cases where 3-9 | + | In most cases where 3-9 lorries are using this station the one way road piece can just be normal road. |
| − | If the Exits/Entrances | + | If the Exits/Entrances don't work well, try placing them centrally on the station sides |
== Real Examples == | == Real Examples == | ||
Courtesy of Public Server game 52 (which as I am writing this is in action) I have a couple of my real stations | Courtesy of Public Server game 52 (which as I am writing this is in action) I have a couple of my real stations | ||
| − | Firstly a big pickup at a forest. Some may argue it | + | Firstly a big pickup at a forest. Some may argue it doesn't need to be this big and I would agree but as I built it with the aim to accommodate the level of trucks in service it's just right and looks alright. It also has a second entrance coupling this was to more evenly distribute lorries as they seemed to pile up on the first row of stations |
[[Image:RdStnConcept_r1.jpg|thumb|center|490px|A real pickup station (big)]] | [[Image:RdStnConcept_r1.jpg|thumb|center|490px|A real pickup station (big)]] | ||
| Line 52: | Line 54: | ||
[[User:Sedontane|Sedontane]] 16:25, 26 July 2007 (UTC) | [[User:Sedontane|Sedontane]] 16:25, 26 July 2007 (UTC) | ||
[[Category:Guides]] | [[Category:Guides]] | ||
| + | [[Category:Basic networking]] | ||
Latest revision as of 09:18, 4 December 2013
 |
This article has been marked as having of out-of-date information. Please help improve the article by updating it. There may be additional information on the talk page. |
 |
This article may need to be updated. Please update this article to reflect recent events or newly available information, and remove this template when finished. Please see the talk page for more information. |
Road stations typically take a back seat to rail stations in #openttdcoop games. Railways have much higher capacities than roadways and trains move much faster than trucks and buses. However, road stations (especially when properly used) can be used to improve parts of a network where a train would be overkill.
2 Key Points
Firstly, since the RoRo road stations were introduced it is much better to use these than terminus stations. A terminus road station is as inefficient as a standard terminus rail station. 1 vehicle may enter and leave at a time which greatly reduces efficiency as with the RoRo one 2 may enter and leave at once, that 4 vehicles in play an efficiency boost of 400% if used constantly.
Routes can be created with the addition of one way roads in a recent nightly, see OpenTTD Wiki: One way roads for more details. Routing is essential if you want an efficient station. At the moment the best stations I can create for busy road stations is 150-200% as you have to force lorries in and out in 1 direction. If 1-way RoRo stations could be created where road vehicles used both sides of the road in one direction this would boost it up to 300-400%.
So the two key points are:
- Don't use Terminus stations - Always route traffic
Traffic Congestion
To create a good station you need to have enough bays now this is individual to each instance of a road station and must be played about with accordingly.
My station concept requires minimal station walking but not in the traditional sense it requires a 1 tile space between each station and its neighbors.
When stations are completed delete walkers. Then place roads to link stations and link roads through the gaps you created For this next image I expanded my station slightly
This as you may have noticed doesnt have routing and so I will build in routing West to East.
Note: Please use distant-join Stations, How press CTRL while Building. In trunk since r14121.
Exits and Entrances
Where to put them in and pull them out! This decision is one of the most important as it determines whether traffic piles up or flows smoothly
I so far have found that Big stations require a different pattern to little ones. For big stations it is good practice to put vehicles in at one corner on one side and pull them from the opposite corner like so.
Also I find it is good practice to note at both ends of Entry/Exit roads the direction in which they travel
This is my design for a small industry pickup (for a big pickup copy the above design scaling station numbers as required)
In most cases where 3-9 lorries are using this station the one way road piece can just be normal road.
If the Exits/Entrances don't work well, try placing them centrally on the station sides
Real Examples
Courtesy of Public Server game 52 (which as I am writing this is in action) I have a couple of my real stations
Firstly a big pickup at a forest. Some may argue it doesn't need to be this big and I would agree but as I built it with the aim to accommodate the level of trucks in service it's just right and looks alright. It also has a second entrance coupling this was to more evenly distribute lorries as they seemed to pile up on the first row of stations
And this is the resulting drop, unusually it has a small forest attached which has another station with lorries running between the two and it is smaller than the pickup but copes well with a good flow rate.
Final Word
Of course I only have my experience so far and will be investigating these items further to further increase the quality of this guide but I hope you have found it useful. feel free to improve this guide with your own thoughts
Sedontane 16:25, 26 July 2007 (UTC)
